Pimpernel Smith
Tone Deaf Daddy
- Messages
- 10,809
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Ringo was great for that stuff. But you wouldn't want him in your little jazz combo. OTOH Charlie Watts was a good drummer as well as great by doing his thing for the Stones.In my experience a lot of classically trained musicians don't get/understand the genius behind the subtlety and nuances in popular music. Sloppy drummer: Ringo; very limited cod-military marching band style: Chris Frantz and case in point: Keith Moon. But their drumming style was essential to the bands they were in.
It's very obvious that Keith was a brilliant drummer with tremendous craft and technique. When individuals say that he lacked technique and he was all over the place, but reluctantly agree that it worked, it's because they don't understand why it works. For people like me, non-musicians, we don't have any baggage of theory and rules, so we instinctively are able to go with the flow and it never crosses our mind that Keith Moon is nothing less than a genius in his drumming craft.
“When people talk about the '60s I never think that was me there. It was me and I was in it, but I was never enamoured with all that. It's supposed to be sex and drugs and rock and roll and I'm not really like that. I've never really seen the Rolling Stones as anything.”
What about the younger bunch like Florence and the Machine?
Florence, she was all right. Lady Gaga was a really good sport. But they hung about with my granddaughter more than they did with me. We're silly old farts! I think Mick tries to keep up with them …
Ringo was great for that stuff. But you wouldn't want him in your little jazz combo. OTOH Charlie Watts was a good drummer as well as great by doing his thing for the Stones.
Probably my lack of care in writing. I don't think poorly of Ringo at all - just the opposite. One of the best rock drummers around - probably rate him and Jim Keltner as the best. Still probably wouldn't ask him to join my Jazz ComboRingo Starr was a good drummer, like a lot of naturally-left handed people of his time, he was ambidextrous (he was forced to write with his right hand when young). He learned to play on a right handed drum kit, and has continued to play a right handed kit. This is he reason that some of his drum parts are very difficult for other drummers to play. Starr, before he joined The Beatles, was widely regarded as the best drummer in Liverpool. George Martin would have had him removed if he wasn't good enough, as he did Pete Best.
IMO a number of things lead to Starr being underrated by the public (he's not underrated by pro-drummers):
1. He is an easy-going character who doesn't blow his own trumpet like Ginger Baker.
2. His playing style is understated, he rarely if ever show boated like Keith Moon.
3. People take Lennon's [alleged] quip seriously.
Here's Mick Taylor on why he left The Stones. Notice his remark about how sloppy The Stones were when he first started playing for them.
http://www.micktaylor.net/why_mick_taylor_quit_the_stones.html
Probably my lack of care in writing. I don't think poorly of Ringo at all - just the opposite. One of the best rock drummers around - probably rate him and Jim Keltner as the best. Still probably wouldn't ask him to join my Jazz Combo
I have to admit that, as a drummer, I've never liked Ringo Starr. It's a personal appreciation that has nothing to do with finesse, technique or whatever. Just don't like his style, his groove, his sound. I'd take one Bonham over 1000 Starr's any day.