Who do you think are the true good makers left nowadays?
I think nowadays the true good makers are the one who keep their quality (no matter the costs)
Grade A+ (not in any particularly order)
Kiton- they still have the same artisans that they had at least 12 years ago. Now they are more vertical than before since they own Carlo Barbera Mill
Colombo - there is no doubt this is true roots in wool/cashmere, they makes only for their own name because they are a lot smaller than others
- they are the only one who have an 40mm fibre nowadays and use around 38mm fibre in their blend garments with silk
- owner brother in law is in charge to yarn and take care of some of their Xinjiang region hircus goats
- their 1 ply fibre is the same quality as the 4 ply garments
- if you are in Italy you can go in their warehouse with pictures of some garment that you want and if they have the material they will do it for you(same as with Kiton). They even do 12 ply garments at request since they dont believe there is high demand for heavier cashmere garments.
Cesare Attolini/Fioroni(owned by CA) - great stuff, great artisans, great quality, more reduce in cashmere/wool levels compared to Kiton/Colombo; what i mean by that is that Kiton/Colombo you have some nice process to receive something remarkable but also delicate, for example kiton has even supers 300 if you want, Colombo has 12.8microns wool that is very delicate but very refined, Colombo also has something they named it cashmere 4.0, extremely light worsted cashmere incredible fibre. At Fioroni/CA you have that old school cashmere. I have an classic navy 4 ply cashmere from them that is 4 years old and still remarkable every time i wear it
Grade A
Loro Piana - great quality, but the shape can be a hit or miss on some particularly individuals and can look like tent on them, not the same level of "know how" artisans like on those from Grade A+ , also the consistency must be improved
Malo - great quality, still, also like i said has the same consistency issue but still, great garment
Brunello Cucinelli - great quality, luxurious feel of the colours
Colhays- great starter like i mention, true to its definition for now
William Lockie - somehow between , they can be hit or miss but you can blind buy from them ...that old school Scottish feel and fit still in grade B+ at the lowest
Grade B+
Johnstons of Elgin - great stuff, not the same quality as decades ago but still, for their prices you can find great stuff
Ballantyne - - also good stuff, sometimes can be a hit or miss, in my opinion not as great as decades ago
John Laing - right there..not a lot of range to chose from like JoE for example
Hawico - another brand that is spun and knit in Scotland, dont know why is not mention like JoE or Ballantyne
Grade B
Gobi cashmere - ok for an entry level, budget friendly cashmere garments
- some times we had a grade A garment from them..like 1 out of 8..so you cant vouch for it
- always go for the lighter colours from them since they seem of a better quality overall (avoid darker colors...since their fibre is shorter or the process is harder on the garment, cashmere cannot be bleached, the darker colour fades away after some washes or frictions
Another thing we saw that houses like Colombo, Brunello that under the armpit they double seam for more durable place where your most friction is
Still to come from Beeg, Berk, Nadaam for September