I am just back from my holiday in Scotland which I started with a few hours in Hawick before heading north and then to the islands.
I attach a few photos (sorry for the poor quality which is due to the fact that I am totally useless at photography and also for the ones taken inside the Lockie store to the fact that I snapped them without being sure it was authorised).
We started we a quick visit to the Loval mill shop. It offers various items made of wool (blankets...) and tweed. The quality seems quite good although I must admit I know nothing about tweed. It is not my thing, from a style point of view and also because I finds it not soft enough. Unfortunately I could not make any photos
We then walked past a small Pringle shop which we did not even bother to stop at... Considering they do not manufacture in Scotland I saw no point. I later saw some of their products in a few 'woolen mills'. Those woolen mills shops are really targeting the tourist trade and offer mediocre quality goods (this applies to Pringle)
Our first proper stop was at the William Lockie store. We were welcome by a very helpful gentleman who told us about the various mill shops still in existence in Hawick: Apart from WL: Hawico and Johnston's. This confirmed my research: Scott & Charter do not have a factory store.
We stayed quite some time in the store (see photos). I found their quality to be really good but the style often quite boxy. The Shawl collar cardigans you see on the pics are lambswool. I tried a couple and the fit was fairly standard/ contemporary. They had a few cashmere ones on sale but unfortunately not in my size (the sale had already been running for a couple of months) except for one which armholes and sleeves were very wide (not the case of the others...).
I ended up purchasing only a 1 ply merino polo shirt with defect that is branded Anderson & Sheppard and Ms Swiss a few pairs of cashmere socks.
The shopkeeper mentioned that they manufacture for many different brands and retail stores (he would not mention them though...). In the store I could see the one Anderson & Sheppard item I mentioned (he said they make a lot for them and had a whole shipment ready to go next door). They also had some socks branded Marinella and Falke...
The shopkeeper mentioned that their business is growing healthily and that the order book is full until next spring. Nice to hear!
Our next stop was at Johnston where we had booked a factory tour. The tour was very interesting and we were lucky enough to be just the two of us and be guided by an employee who had been around for many years. No photos allowed unfortunately but we could see all the manufacturing steps and got the chance to ask lots of questions. We also had quite a long chat with a lady in charge of quality control for Chanel products. The fact that Johnston's makes for Chanel was a discovery to me. We also saw a bunch of items for Burberry's (hats and scarves with burberry written all over, the type of items I would never have thought would be made in scotland...). The lady also confirmed that Hermes is a customer along with many others she would not mention.
We then proceeded to the factory store where I purchased an unlined and unstructured thick cashmere blazer and a tartan blanket. Their knits look nice but I was unimpressed by the tension. I must say though that Mrs Swiss has had a few of their items for a few years, including a thick cardigan, and they have held up well the test of handwashing.
Johnston has made their factory store into a very nice space with coffee shop... Lockie on the other hand is what I consider a real factory store: lots of stuff crammed on hangers without much merchandising effort at all.
The shop assistant mentioned they hold a sales week during the first week of December, with deep discounts. Ms Swiss might go if she happens to visit family...
Our last stop was at Hawico (a brand I did not know well at all although they have a store in Geneva...): A nice, large retail space with windows providing a view of the factory.
They had a lot of sweaters and cardigans all priced between 200 and 300 Pounds (I do not know what their retail price is but it seemed pretty heavily discounted according to the retail price shwn on a few labels...). The quality was average in my view. Style-wise, they definitely try to emulate italian makers. Interestingly they also had various garments (coats, shirts, trousers) of various italian makers...
No purchases there.
We then hit the road to the Gleneagles hotel where we had a beautiful stay and tasted some very nice single malts...
PS: the photos are all of William Lockie