The knitwear thread

Here is one of my Brunello Cucinelli. Looks amazing `eh? These days it is pilled and looks a bit tired. It's knitting is not as dense and robust like some of the old Scottish knits. Feels very processed, is all soft and mushy.

Brunello Cucinelli cardigan 2.jpg


Other BC 2 ply knits are more dense, and harder cashmere too, but still pills. Other knits are a loser knit. None-the-less, Brunello Cucinelli makes the most stunning pieces of anyone, IMO.

I've seen some worldclass looking Kiton knitwear online, ie, robust cashmere cableknits, but frightenly expensive. I also own a Tom Ford turtleneck made in the U.K that looks thick and substantial, but in reality it is air light with a less dense knit, ie it is all looks (stunning) but no substance.
 

Attachments

  • Brunello Cucinelli cardigan 1.webp
    Brunello Cucinelli cardigan 1.webp
    21 KB · Views: 65
Last edited:
Again, pilling is a matter of time in our view, in my view...and also a matter of care.
Even small pilling is still a sense that it is 100% cashmere and not with synthetic blend to prevent any pilling
Some of fashion houses are using polyamide with cashmere and there is no pilling, even more the garment is more water resistance, the drops of water are falling on the garment and not sucked in
The bad quality is when the pilling never stop and increases more and more in the quantity of the lose fibres
Garments that are new, and never pills after of couple of days can mean, great quality, but also the other side of the coin...means less quality but the manufacturer extra washed it to prevent pilling at first.
In my eyes i wouldnt compare BC with Kiton...for now. Kiton is still grade A+
But also i wouldnt say BC is not a great quality garment..it looks/feels and it is luxurious, it feels very processed because they need that to reach that colour flavour
 
Last edited:
Hello everyone, my name is C, and I’m a knitwear addict. When I say I have an addiction, it is not an exaggeration: I go absolutely bat sh*t crazy over well-made sweaters.

I am fortunate to live in a part of the world where cold weather creeps in around September and last well into early may, so sweaters are my favourite category of clothing. Hell, even now in the gold of summer, I go for coffee runs in the morning and work from home in light cashmere jumpers.

I keep a spreadsheet of all the clothing I own, and of course a separate one for my knitwear collection, as a way to keep a rein on my sweater addiction. Now at around 100 jumpers in my small, cramped wardrobe, I practice the one-in-one-out approach to keep it under control: If I acquire a new sweater, I must get rid of one.

My go-to staples are crewnecks, half-zips, polos and full zip sweater jackets. My least favourites are v-necks and shawl cardigans. Around 1/4 of my knitwear are LORO PIANA, with the rest being primarily Italian-made.

With almost 100 sweaters in my collection, I can literally wear a different sweater every day for over three months, so a jumper’s durability isn’t my main concern. To me, the most important aspects of a sweater is the quality of fibres used and design (fit, proportions silhouette).

My best sweaters in terms of fibre quality are from LORO PIANA; my most well made sweaters are William Lockie; and my coolest, most interesting sweaters in terms of design - and my most expensive - are from CHANEL.

Thank you for reading. To kick off with a bang, here is my small and humbling vicuna collection.

View attachment 44554
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yes, RL do wonderful traditionally styled jumpers, but why would anyone want to buy there stuff. To me, one doesn't buy just on appearance, but buys mainly on how it is made. RL is made in China...
Their cable knits are alleged to be very good indeed, I haven't any, but I do have some half-zips which are top notch.

They're not only made in China. RL are an equal rag trade sweat shop exploiter i.e. Cambodia, Thailand, India etc, Turkey's back on the approved supplier list now, et al.

I was in Brazil when Ralph Lauren pulled out of the country. The prime reason was that the knock-off stuff sold on the street was to the exact same specification, same standards of quality as the ''real'' deal branded RL gear. They were indistinguishable. As it should be, as it was made in the exact same factories that RL was purchasing from.
 
Hello everyone, my name is C, and I’m a knitwear addict. When I say I have an addiction, it is not an exaggeration: I go absolutely bat sh*t crazy over well-made sweaters.

I am fortunate to live in a part of the world where cold weather creeps in around September and last well into early May, so sweaters are my favorite category of clothing. Hell, even now in the gold of summer, I go for coffee runs in the morning and work from home in light cashmere jumpers.

I keep a spreadsheet of all the clothing I own, and of course a separate one for my knitwear collection, as a way to keep a rein on my sweater addiction. Now at around 100 jumpers in my small, cramped wardrobe, I practice the one-in-one-out approach to keep it under control: If I acquire a new sweater, I must get rid of one.

My go-to staples are crewnecks, half-zips, polos and full zip sweater jackets. My least favorites are v-necks and shawl cardigans. Around 1/4 of my knitwear are LORO PIANA, with the rest being primarily Italian-made.

With almost 100 sweaters in my collection, I can literally wear a different sweater every day for over three months, so a jumper’s durability isn’t my main concern. To me, the most important aspects of a sweater is the quality of fibres used and design (fit, proportions silhouette).

My best sweaters in terms of fibre quality are from LORO PIANA; my most well made sweaters are William Lockie; and my coolest, most interesting sweaters in terms of design - and my most expensive - are from CHANEL.

Thank you for reading. To kick off with a bang, here is my small and humbling vicuna collection.

View attachment 44554

Thanks for sharing CHANEL . Knitwear addicts are different to most people, instead knitwear addicts look forward to the cold weather. Most people are the opposite, they love the nicer weather, but not us jumper folk.

Nice that you have a vicuna collection. Do you enjoy vicuna more than cashmere? How does Vicuna compare to cashmere in your opinion?
 
such as the reinforced armpit seams (althoug it is not on all pieces)

I believe Swiss here was referring to Hermès. The reinforced armpit seams can also be found in William Lockie (WL), along with roll-back cuffs and mother of pearl buttons (on cashmere polos). Quality features. No reinforced armpit seams found in Loro Piana (LP) or Brunello Cucinelli (BC), at least in the pieces I own.

You also mentioned qiviuk. I think it is over-rated.

I respectfully disagree. I own a 100% qiviuk crewneck in natural undyed brown/gray color. Simply exquisite and my warmest jumper.

Had a very unpleasant experience with Berk.

I 500% concur. I would NOT recommend Berk to anyone. Classless fraud.

Source: I too had an awful experience with Berk.

I would say that it's more so the brands have accepted China's labor rather than China purposefully restricting their options.

I would NOT consider Chinese labor cheap nowadays. It's actually (more and more) expensive.

^I'd love to find a good Fair Isle jumper, preferably at a price that isn't outrageous.

View attachment 44605

I own this one from BC and I love. Alpaca, virgin wool, cashmere and silk blend.

Those double thick collars are amazing, but l passed because it was lambswool where-as l only do cashmere.

View attachment 44606

I own this one from Hermès and love the double thick collars. Riri zippers, 12-ply, 5-gauge. Quality of the highest order.

Additionally, I don't believe all the sellers claiming to sell 8- or 12-ply or whatever versions.

I agree. In the Hermès example above, even though the description says 12 fils, jauge 5 (12 ply, gauge 5), I reckon it's really 6 strands of 2/28 yarn, making it 6 ply in technical terms.

also want to try Llama and Yak fibres too.

I own a yak-blend cardigan from Banana Republic and it is robust. A less impressive one from Frank & Oak with 50% merino wool and 50% yak.

Hermes made-in-Scotland cashmere is the best made today.
Currently, Hermès sells jumpers made in Italy or the UK (I believe still from a Scottish producer). BUT the UK-made jumpers are less than impressive; by this I mean very loosely knit. In contrast, the zipped sweater pictured above is made in Italy and is quality, thick and plush.

View attachment 44607

Hermes (made-in-Scotland) is in a different league from the rest because it has denser knitting, thicker ply, higher gauge, uses mother-of-pearl

Barrie is now owned by Chanel and the quality is supposed to be excellent (while the styling is debatable, as you say).
I can attest to this - pictured below a thick jumper made by Barrie for Chanel. Excellent knit tension, substantial Scottish cashmere.

View attachment 44609
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for the suggestion. John Laing is indeed one of the few interesting makers left.
Looking it up on Google maps, I realise that they are just next door to Barrie (and Glenmac...).
I will try and phone them up to see if there is a factory store (although I doubt it).
This brings me back quite a few years when I was a student in the UK and I went for a one week trip to Scotland and visited a couple of factory stores in Hawick. This was quite a few years ago and Scottish cashmere was still up there... I dont expect such a good experience this time round unfortunately.
John Laing is Barrie made just a john Laing label/brand same factory
 
I found these whilst packing for my forthcoming move. And the latest Supima cotton roll neck from Lands End...

20220818_014526.jpg
20220818_014605.jpg
20220817_005620.jpg
 
how is 90% merino wool? still retain the efficiency on smell and odor-restitant ?! Does that 10% cashmere matters in that aspect?

Please tell me more about odor resistance of cashmere v's wool. I find cashmere to be amazingly odor resistant.

J Johnny amazing knitwear, truly stunning. Can you please tell me who made the:
- polos
- button mock necks
- cableknits
 
Please tell me more about odor resistance of cashmere v's wool. I find cashmere to be amazingly odor resistant.

J Johnny amazing knitwear, truly stunning. Can you please tell me who made the:
- polos
- button mock necks
- cableknits
Yes, in general 100% merino wool it is the most odor resistance from all the natural fibres out there because of its moisture wicking properties
No wonder the 1 ply cashmere makers are entering into the market in the last years. Its the only way to compete with cotton/linen/ merino wool in the warmer climate or warmer season/s. But of course 1ply cashmere can be hit or miss depending from who are you buying because if the fibre is of a lower quality degree that 1ply garment its a waste of money, truly. You can get away with lower degree of the yarn with 4ply or higher, heavier garment because of the weight and how much cashmere its in it, it will pill, rubber of course but it will not be destroyed like the lower grade 1 ply cashmere
Merino wool is one of the best in keeping you dry almost sweat-free because of how the merino wool fibre interact with the skin and your sweat. Until now, we never/i never had anything but merino wool from the "higher super numbers" most coming from Zegna and their 12 microns wool. Unfortunately i never had to tear apart for example an super s240 or higher. I heard Kiton reached s300, i would love to see something like that something under 10 microns just from technical achievements point of view because i would never buy something that so delicate
 
Last edited:
From what i see in the last week, i would recommend Begg&Co instead of Berk
Beggs Lambswool is wonderful , we got some green dyed garments and they are nice, the fibre didnt seem to suffered from the washing and dyeing processes
On the other hand Berk not so much, while i got a lighter colour normal wool, everything looked like they really tried to see how longer it lasts...maybe it was dyed and then bleached or their mill from where they take the yarns is very harsh on it...Testing and retesting it is ok in closed doors and after kept in the mill, but not on something that is sold to the customers
I wonder if anyone have an older Berk around here and how it lasts, if it was washed multiple times and so on and how are the pigments in the fibre holding on
I think nowadays there should be more restrictive laws ..Grade A in this business means almost every seller that sells wool/cashmere any knitwear
I mean, no offence to Gobi Cashmere and a lot others...but that is sold in specifications as Grade A like others, like Brunello, Loro, William Lockie and im not even counting our Grade A+ houses . This allow a lot of makers to sell for premium price, inferior quality, but again this is just my opinion. And UE it is said that are making laws to protect and towards the customers..i think in this business they are behind
 
Last edited:
I have built up a collection of Merino roll necks. I can't wait until autumn.

I have the following:

John Smedley - quite a few
Gran Sasso
John Henric
Uniqlo
Asos x2
 
I have built up a collection of Merino roll necks. I can't wait until autumn.

I have the following:

John Smedley - quite a few
Gran Sasso
John Henric
Uniqlo
Asos x2
So all except one are 100% merino wool? Or can you give us the composition on each? i know you have one 90 merino+10 cashmere(Kilgour)
Another question, how is the roll neck from that Asos? from the look of it, is less sturdy and more relaxed
Thank you
 
Anyone know about this company?



Looks likes a very basic cut, ie, sagging at neck and sleeves look constructed at a flat bench etc (see pictures of lad wearing the submariner). Only a 5 gauge knit.
 
From what i see in the last week, i would recommend Begg&Co instead of Berk
Beggs Lambswool is wonderful , we got some green dyed garments and they are nice, the fibre didnt seem to suffered from the washing and dyeing processes
On the other hand Berk not so much, while i got a lighter colour normal wool, everything looked like they really tried to see how longer it lasts...maybe it was dyed and then bleached or their mill from where they take the yarns is very harsh on it...Testing and retesting it is ok in closed doors and after kept in the mill, but not on something that is sold to the customers
I wonder if anyone have an older Berk around here and how it lasts, if it was washed multiple times and so on and how are the pigments in the fibre holding on
I think nowadays there should be more restrictive laws ..Grade A in this business means almost every seller that sells wool/cashmere any knitwear
I mean, no offence to Gobi Cashmere and a lot others...but that is sold in specifications as Grade A like others, like Brunello, Loro, William Lockie and im not even counting our Grade A+ houses . This allow a lot of makers to sell for premium price, inferior quality, but again this is just my opinion. And UE it is said that are making laws to protect and towards the customers..i think in this business they are behind

Would be interesting to hear how long the fibers are in the Begg cashmere scarves v's their jumpers/cardigans. Would be good to know if their jumpers are as good as the scarves. Do Begg actually make their jumpers?

Begg and Co 8 ply and 5 gauge in cashmere
Begg & Co 8 ply shawl cardigan.jpg
Begg & Co shawl cardigan 1.jpg
Begg & Co shawl cardigan 2  8 ply.jpg


Begg charge almost 900 GBP for these 8 ply shawls, but still only half the price Ballantyne was charging for their 6 ply shawls 14 years ago. What corners have been cut to be charging so little??
 
Anyone know about this company?



Looks likes a very basic cut, ie, sagging at neck and sleeves look constructed at a flat bench etc (see pictures of lad wearing the submariner). Only a 5 gauge knit.


Yes. I have a bunch of their pieces. Really good construction and durable. The quality of the material is pretty decent

1661160689354.webp
 
Yes. I have a bunch of their pieces. Really good construction and durable. The quality of the material is pretty decent

View attachment 44699

Might be good for a few basic submariners for mucking around. Not very tight knitting though.
 
Would be interesting to hear how long the fibers are in the Begg cashmere scarves v's their jumpers/cardigans. Would be good to know if their jumpers are as good as the scarves. Do Begg actually make their jumpers?

Begg and Co 8 ply and 5 gauge in cashmere
View attachment 44696View attachment 44697View attachment 44698

Begg charge almost 900 GBP for these 8 ply shawls, but still only half the price Ballantyne was charging for their 6 ply shawls 14 years ago. What corners have been cut to be charging so little??
You can cut corners by" cutting a lot of middle mens" Thats how for example Cesare Attolini kept their prices while keeping the same ace quality even with the infaltion, by being even more vertical and take Fioroni with all their expertise/artisans and mill under their own company
900GBP for a Begg heavy shawls on retail price is right there, it is the right price based on the quality IF the quality persist among all of their catalogue
If Begg was more known and with a lot more marketing price inflicted, that garment could costs over 1200 GBP just because of the marketing and the "middle men" not based on the quality change. Remember , better marketing means more money to pay by the maker and by its customers but the quality remains the same
So hopefully great houses, our A+ makers should remain like they are for the last decade...where their marketing is their garment itself. Their garments speak for themselves
 
Anyone know about this company?



Looks likes a very basic cut, ie, sagging at neck and sleeves look constructed at a flat bench etc (see pictures of lad wearing the submariner). Only a 5 gauge knit.

They use one of the main manufacturers, which could be:

Crystal/Richmond
Paul James
Outdoor
 
You can cut corners by" cutting a lot of middle mens" Thats how for example Cesare Attolini kept their prices while keeping the same ace quality even with the infaltion, by being even more vertical and take Fioroni with all their expertise/artisans and mill under their own company
900GBP for a Begg heavy shawls on retail price is right there, it is the right price based on the quality IF the quality persist among all of their catalogue
If Begg was more known and with a lot more marketing price inflicted, that garment could costs over 1200 GBP just because of the marketing and the "middle men" not based on the quality change. Remember , better marketing means more money to pay by the maker and by its customers but the quality remains the same
So hopefully great houses, our A+ makers should remain like they are for the last decade...where their marketing is their garment itself. Their garments speak for themselves

If Ballantyne was still in business, a 6 ply shawl cardigan might well be 3,000 GBP, so maybe 4 - 5 times higher priced than the Begg or Lockie. So is the extra cost mainly caught up in the marketing and `name'?? Hard to say for sure without knowing how the company is set up, but interesting to think about sometimes. I Understand that Ballantyne made in Italy tried to market similar to Brunello Cucinelli category and be like them, but despite the famous name they didn't pull it off.

I remember the Hermes 2 ply v neck jumpers made about 4 years ago. The ones made in Italy were half the price of the ones made in Scotland...makes me wonder why the price difference??

Then there are these by Chanel, made by their own Barrie factory. BIG name, BIG marketing budget.

$8,010 ASD for silk cashmere blend

$7,700 for pure cashmere. Much more expensive than the Hermes jumpers, but much more design element going on here and more fancy features. Much would be due to the NAME and marketing too.
 
Anyone know about this company?



Looks likes a very basic cut, ie, sagging at neck and sleeves look constructed at a flat bench etc (see pictures of lad wearing the submariner). Only a 5 gauge knit.

IIRC Thruth Thruth recommended some of their stuff a while back.
 
If Ballantyne was still in business, a 6 ply shawl cardigan might well be 3,000 GBP, so maybe 4 - 5 times higher priced than the Begg or Lockie. So is the extra cost mainly caught up in the marketing and `name'?? Hard to say for sure without knowing how the company is set up, but interesting to think about sometimes. I Understand that Ballantyne made in Italy tried to market similar to Brunello Cucinelli category and be like them, but despite the famous name they didn't pull it off.

I remember the Hermes 2 ply v neck jumpers made about 4 years ago. The ones made in Italy were half the price of the ones made in Scotland...makes me wonder why the price difference??

Then there are these by Chanel, made by their own Barrie factory. BIG name, BIG marketing budget.

$8,010 ASD for silk cashmere blend

$7,700 for pure cashmere. Much more expensive than the Hermes jumpers, but much more design element going on here and more fancy features. Much would be due to the NAME and marketing too.
Exactly. Those Chanel probably cost extra 25% marketing+25% name+extra for the outside designers+some little jewellery
Men should not pay for that when they have Kiton or CA around there...people with money that dont know what fit and quality means keeps those brands on the market with those prices. Thats why i put that statement of mine earlier..if there were more restrictive and more aggressive quality laws check and class grade, these prices would never be around here with so much profit for those big names
Cashmere and suit from Gerogio Armani are good in fit but garbage in quality, but the prices are up there where are not belong and telling the whole truth
Fit and quality both matter for me personally, if the fit is right but the quality is garbage is a waste of money, the vice versa if the quality is there but the fit is wrong...again waste of money
 
Last edited:
Might be good for a few basic submariners for mucking around. Not very tight knitting though.
Looks loose but it’s actually not. And quite heavy
 
I am just back from my holiday in Scotland which I started with a few hours in Hawick before heading north and then to the islands.

I attach a few photos (sorry for the poor quality which is due to the fact that I am totally useless at photography and also for the ones taken inside the Lockie store to the fact that I snapped them without being sure it was authorised).

We started we a quick visit to the Loval mill shop. It offers various items made of wool (blankets...) and tweed. The quality seems quite good although I must admit I know nothing about tweed. It is not my thing, from a style point of view and also because I finds it not soft enough. Unfortunately I could not make any photos

We then walked past a small Pringle shop which we did not even bother to stop at... Considering they do not manufacture in Scotland I saw no point. I later saw some of their products in a few 'woolen mills'. Those woolen mills shops are really targeting the tourist trade and offer mediocre quality goods (this applies to Pringle)

Our first proper stop was at the William Lockie store. We were welcome by a very helpful gentleman who told us about the various mill shops still in existence in Hawick: Apart from WL: Hawico and Johnston's. This confirmed my research: Scott & Charter do not have a factory store.
We stayed quite some time in the store (see photos). I found their quality to be really good but the style often quite boxy. The Shawl collar cardigans you see on the pics are lambswool. I tried a couple and the fit was fairly standard/ contemporary. They had a few cashmere ones on sale but unfortunately not in my size (the sale had already been running for a couple of months) except for one which armholes and sleeves were very wide (not the case of the others...).

I ended up purchasing only a 1 ply merino polo shirt with defect that is branded Anderson & Sheppard and Ms Swiss a few pairs of cashmere socks.

The shopkeeper mentioned that they manufacture for many different brands and retail stores (he would not mention them though...). In the store I could see the one Anderson & Sheppard item I mentioned (he said they make a lot for them and had a whole shipment ready to go next door). They also had some socks branded Marinella and Falke...

The shopkeeper mentioned that their business is growing healthily and that the order book is full until next spring. Nice to hear!

Our next stop was at Johnston where we had booked a factory tour. The tour was very interesting and we were lucky enough to be just the two of us and be guided by an employee who had been around for many years. No photos allowed unfortunately but we could see all the manufacturing steps and got the chance to ask lots of questions. We also had quite a long chat with a lady in charge of quality control for Chanel products. The fact that Johnston's makes for Chanel was a discovery to me. We also saw a bunch of items for Burberry's (hats and scarves with burberry written all over, the type of items I would never have thought would be made in scotland...). The lady also confirmed that Hermes is a customer along with many others she would not mention.
We then proceeded to the factory store where I purchased an unlined and unstructured thick cashmere blazer and a tartan blanket. Their knits look nice but I was unimpressed by the tension. I must say though that Mrs Swiss has had a few of their items for a few years, including a thick cardigan, and they have held up well the test of handwashing.
Johnston has made their factory store into a very nice space with coffee shop... Lockie on the other hand is what I consider a real factory store: lots of stuff crammed on hangers without much merchandising effort at all.

The shop assistant mentioned they hold a sales week during the first week of December, with deep discounts. Ms Swiss might go if she happens to visit family...

Our last stop was at Hawico (a brand I did not know well at all although they have a store in Geneva...): A nice, large retail space with windows providing a view of the factory.
They had a lot of sweaters and cardigans all priced between 200 and 300 Pounds (I do not know what their retail price is but it seemed pretty heavily discounted according to the retail price shwn on a few labels...). The quality was average in my view. Style-wise, they definitely try to emulate italian makers. Interestingly they also had various garments (coats, shirts, trousers) of various italian makers...
No purchases there.

We then hit the road to the Gleneagles hotel where we had a beautiful stay and tasted some very nice single malts...

PS: the photos are all of William Lockie
IMG_7180[1].webp
IMG_7176[1].webp
IMG_7178[1].webp
IMG_7179[1].webp
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We then hit the road to the Gleneagles hotel where we had a beautiful stay and tasted some very nice single malts...

Now we are getting somewhere.

I have bought Johnstons stuff for eons myself, it's all held up very well.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom