Sarto, while I'm reading your posts and try to learn from them, they sound to me as if you were angry with every other shirtmaker that is not you or someone else that you like or learned from. It's obvious that we would defend our stuff and the one from other that we like.
I think that at the end this is business. And some of these shirtmakers make good business. My cousin, for example, he loves Carolina Herrera shirts, he doesn't want a bespoke shirt or MTM or anything else if it's not Carolina Herrera. You could give him a full lesson of all the hand work that goes into a bespoker shirt made by you or Anna Matuzzo or someone like that and he still will be coosing the CH shirt. Even when they don't fit him nicely. So if you are not CH, he will not buy from you. It's silly but his friends think the same and how many other in the world think the same so that's why all these big brands are shaping their customers taste.
It's funny when he sees someone that has the same shirt and it's wearing it at the same time he is, because he get mad, but if you are buying OTR that's going to happen.
To resume, your posts are good but they have the feeling or sensation that you are angry/jealous of them instead of being enlightening posts.
Just my 2 cents, not intended as an offense.
Ha, First of all, envy and jealous is a feeling of inferior destructive people, creative superior people do admire instead in order to improve it. I admire Anna Mattuozzo, my Borrelli masters ,real old Savile Row ( no Jermyn sorry, never liked English shirts or even considered them average compared to neapolitans) and who ever does a good garment, sadly just a few on the world at this time. The rest, I hate them, specially scammers or brands who sell smoke.
2, yes I am angry and hate them all, black, white, unwhite, asian, gentile, russian, american, indian, martian, annunaki, reptilians, spanish, democrat, republican, I just hate them all and be happy.
CH shirts; I have a corner of it on my city so I am very familiar with, fused suits and 1000 euros price, poor shirts with baggy fit and obnoxious sizing, I got a size 4 ?¿?¿ ( This is old Spanish sizing, was different from measuring the collar as per example 15,5 inches/40 cms collar circunference. This shirt that had the equivalent of a 40 collar, got the body of a 44. As you see, obnoxious and very out of the Italian rtw way of using studies of anatomy from the last century to do a garment that fits as much people as possible with still a beauty silhouette on the fit.
It was one of my first experiments years ago of how to diminish / repattern a shirt body, not taking in sides, but completely reshape the body.
I sell it for 20 euros, tell you cousin.
Fabrics are less than poor, super thick over 250 grams ( Riva is just 65) and caliber like 40/2, a real neapolitan shirt goes over 170/2 up ( 35 euros meter vs. 2 euros meter)
Collars got one of the worst interlining made, i think is called Manley, a horrible catalonian copy of european interlinings. Feeling wearing a CH shirt with tie on is like being hanged by a rope.
I got the bad experience I called them before my Kiton masters told me was the worst interlining ever, not only they lied me telling the best interlining brand was out of business, when the week prior, the truck with my order arrived, while I got friendship with the french boss, but when I told him this fact, the narcissistic told me, now go Naples and do pizza!!!
Remember the drug addict liar I exposed last week, he sent me to those Manley. Yes the same who said MOP buttons get broken easily and plastic ones are better, when is the contrary.
The only CH garment I like are ties, average making, 100 euros price for a 3 fold machine made, never even on sales go lesser than 100 euros, but use top Como´s silk, not cheapo silk as Armani or other fashionistas on the same level use.
Best.